Monday, November 8, 2010
Almost there....
Monday, June 9, 2008
He does seem to be getting better....
There are still issues with inattentiveness and impulsivity, but generally Georges' progress is described as very good. It's difficult to quantify because we have no real starting point from which to measure him. We do, however, have the "event logs" and this is where we can draw some conclusions from.
As previously mentioned, January was pretty awful, as was February (I found out today) and March was particularly hair curling.... All three months showed numerous negative event logs and each month seemed to be worse than the month before.
Mr W told me today, that 'they' would normally expect to move on from there to discussions about different schooling options - we have a couple of schools in our area for children with challenging behaviour (which I refer to as schools for "naughty children" and have often threatened George with this).
George has completely thrown them, by turning everything on it's head. April was better, May was better still and so far (fingers crossed) there is only one event log for June and that is a massive positive given by a Teacher who doesn't take any prisoners - so coming from her it's real Kudos! :o)
We talked about the possible reasons behind this new attitude that George has. Because there is no science behind it, we have to make certain assumptions. Mr W is a very experienced teacher and can quote chapter and verse on children with ADHD. He has a very good understanding of the problems associated with these children and how best to deal with them. He couldn't understand how George could improve so much in such a short space of time.
We talked about the possibility of his "wake up call" in March, when he was in quite serious trouble on at least two occasions. We also agreed that whilst it may have had some impact, it cannot be the only reason for this massive improvement (ADHD children don't seem to be able to recall how their behaviour negatively impacted on anybody else or themselves).
We talked about the possibility of natural maturation, but discounted that because of the huge gains made in such a comparatively small length of time.
The only other thing we could pin it on is The Dore Programme.
So..... we talked about that for a while. Mr W hadn't heard of it before I mentioned it a couple of months ago. He has asked around and found only limited information, so, because people weren't jumping up and down about it, I think he rather discounted it.
He asked me why, if it's so good, isn't the Government introducing it into school?
I gave him the simple answer - lack of clinical research.
Unfortunately, I then got on my high horse....
If Dore had spent several million pounds (and numerous years) on clinical research, we probably wouldn't have access to this programme, even now. It would still be in the research phase, surely? I don't know.... I'm not a research expert..... but I think that most of these alternative forms of therapy are, in the main, belittled by mainstream doctors and specialists. As a society, I think many of us are very critical of anything which is outside the norm and is termed "alternative".
Ritalin, on the other hand, is well known, has been used for at least 40 years, and has clinical research behind it to prove that it works. Until recently, what it didn't have, was research into the long term efficacy, along with any long term side effects.
Last November, in the UK, there was a Panorama programme about a boy called Craig, who had been taking Ritalin for his chronic ADHD. This was a follow up programme to a previous "snapshot" of Craig, which was taken in 2000.
The 2007 programme was filmed specifically because there were new results announced regarding Ritalin and it's long term benefits.
The results, in a nutshell, are that there are NO long term benefits to taking Ritalin, and the quote made by Professor William Pelham, a world authority on ADHD is most worrying:
"I think that we exaggerated the beneficial impact of medication in the first study. We had thought that children medicated longer would have better outcomes. That didn't happen to be the case. There's no indication that medication's better than nothing in the long run."
If I were able to choose, right now, between Ritalin and nothing, based on that comment, and what I have seen my child go through whilst taking this drug, I would choose nothing. What mother wouldn't?
Why is this information not being plastered all over the newspapers?
We're living in a "quick fix" society, that's why (in my opinion).
Once I had dismounted from my high horse, we continued our discussion and I discovered this:
It would seem that there are an increasing number of General Practitioners (in our area) who are now refusing to regularly write prescriptions for Ritalin. Why is this? Could it be that there is now a huge question mark over what was once perceived as the correct treatment for ADHD?
Why is it, when the proof is there in black and white, that parents are being told that Ritalin is the only way forward for these children?
Why is it, that our children have been prescribed this potentially mind-altering drug when the research into the long term effects has been (up until recently) severely lacking?
Why is it OK to accept this lack of research regarding Ritalin, but our clinicians will not accept the lack of research when The Dore Programme is presented as a very good possible alternative.
Go back a few paragraphs:
There's no indication that medication's better than nothing in the long run.
Is what the Professor said, and he's a world renowned authority on ADHD.
OK... I'll take that NOTHING and raise it with The Dore Programme
I win the game, I believe.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
You want to what?.....
Last time we went, in November 2007, we were told that we would be called back in three months because we had taken George off his meds. Sure enough, 6 months later....... *rolls eyes*
We haven't seen the same Doctor twice in the five years that George has been visiting. Yesterday was no exception. We made that comment and the Doctor apologised profusely and went on to explain about staff shortages and how he, as a consultant Psychiatrist, had been called in to help out. Whilst I am fully aware of the shortcomings of the NHS in terms of resources, it shouldn't be my problem. I'm not really interested in the problems faced by the NHS, I am more interested in the problems faced by my son, and ensuring that he gets the correct support.
I felt a bit sorry for the chap, to be honest. We told him exactly how we felt - that we had been abandoned by the system and left to our own devices. How, in January and February, we were at our wits end and the only support we could get was a telephone call from a hard pressed ADHD nurse, three days to a week after we called asking for help!
In fairness to him, he had read all the notes, and he asked if George was taking any medication at all. This obviously led on to a conversation about The Dore Programme. I was surprised to know that he had heard of it, and he told me that he was attending a Psychiatrists convention shortly, and Dore was on the agenda. He has also seen one other child in our area who is on The Dore Programme and this other child is also making some good progress.
We discussed the cost involved. I'm not a Rocket Scientist, but even I can see that Dore could actually save the NHS money, if only they would get behind it. I have no idea how much Ritalin costs, but 18000mg per year for five years must cost more than a few pence..... add to that the cost of the resources - psychiatrists, support staff, ADHD nurses etc., and the five years that George has spent within the system must have cost more than £2500. Had we not discovered Dore, George would be faced with at least two visits per year for .... I don't know how many more years. Again a cost factor when comparing traditional ADHD management with The Dore Programme.
We also discussed the "leap of faith" factor. Yes, I know that Dore doesn't work for everybody, and I'm sure if the people at Dore could identify why it doesn't work for all then they could possibly take some steps to refine the programme. Perhaps in the future this may come to pass.
Whilst we were talking, George (bless him) was sat quietly next to me. He was sketching a hot rod and I noticed how calm he was, how relaxed, how totally focussed he was on what he was doing. This is not something he has ever managed to do successfully when there is something else going on in the same room. The Doctors words "He's like a different boy" will stick in my mind for some time to come..... and as I'm typing these words, I'm grinning like an idiot....!
He is like a different boy, he's calmer, quieter, more content and we have noticed this, but it's doubly impressive when other people notice. The Doctor admitted that he was apprehensive about our meeting and had been racking his brains to find a way to help us. I know that once he met George, and saw the way he behaved so perfectly, he was quite relieved.
To answer the question "You want to what?"....
He wanted to discharge George. He doesn't feel that George needs to go back for any more check ups and is very happy with his progress.
Now... the cynic in me feels that by discharging George, much needed resources will be freed up to deal with the many other children within the system and also on the waiting list. Whilst I am sympathetic, and God knows I realise how frustrating it is to be on a waiting list where you never seem to get to the top, my main concern is my child and his wellbeing. For this reason, I refused to allow him to be discharged. We are very happy with the way George is improving, and I have faith in The Dore Programme. But, we're still only 3 months into it and I want to retain a safety net for 6 months just in case.....
So, we'll get another appointment through in 6 months time, and I'm hopeful that I'll be able to take my perfectly normal son to see them, and sit there with a smug look on my face....
Wednesday, May 7, 2008
Hot and Sweaty...
I spend quite a lot of time working on my PC and over the years have been lucky enough to have a few cyber buddies (people whom I like, but have never met). One of these lovely people asked me last week to explain "the exercises" because she couldn't work out what it was all about. So, for Pat, here are a couple of examples:
Walk five paces forwards, then five paces backwards. Bend to the left three times, then bend to the right three times. Repeat this sequence eight times more.
Using the ball (which looks like a space hopper without the ears), sit down on it with your knees together and your feet together on the floor. Bounce up and down for 1 minute. Then, sit perfectly still on the ball for 1 minute. Close your eyes and bounce up and down for 1 minute. Keeping your eyes closed, sit still for 1 minute.
I also have "real life" friends and am priviledged to have known one of these friends for 30 years. We were chatting a couple of days ago and I was telling her that George needed to eat Salmon twice a week to ensure that he keeps his omega 3 levels fairly high (much better absorption than fish oil capsules). She came up with a really fun way of getting him to eat it, rather than just slapping a fillet of steamed salmon in front of him (it's a bit boring after a while). I'm going to try it this weekend:
Slice one cod fillet and one salmon fillet into strips (gougons). Dip them first into beaten egg, then into home made breadcrumbs and fry them for 3-4 minutes each or until golden brown. The fun bit is you then have a guessing game, whilst eating them: Pink or white? The one who guesses the most right, wins!
I also shared one of those Homer Simpson style "Doh" moments....
It's becoming increasingly difficult to find squash that isn't "no added sugar". It seems these days that everybody is harping on about cutting down on salt, sugar, saturated fat, eggs, cheese..... everything really.... I know! Lets just drink water!
Oops.... there I go, on my high horse again.... I'll get back to the plot....
Sugar free drinks may be better for you in terms of reducing ones sugar intake. What they don't tell you is that the sugar has been replaced with aspartame and this is a HUGE problem, in my experience. My children DO NOT have sugar free drinks because the aspartame causes more problems. For this reason, we always buy high juice squashes (not sugar free ones) or real fruit juice. A couple of weeks ago, George had been particularly helpful and he asked if he could buy some chewing gum. I allowed this and didn't really given it a second thought. The following day, come mid-morning, he had turned into the Tasmanian Devil, was completely uncontrollable, and I started to panic that the Dore Programme had stopped helping him..... Then came the "Doh" moment. I checked the ingredients of the chewing gum, and sure enough, it was sugar free and LOADED with Aspartame. That'll teach me to take my eye off the ball...... thankfully, by the following day he was much calmer.
Finally, in my haste to make my previous blog post, I forgot a rather significant and pleasant occurrence. Earlier in the year (pre-Dore) George was in danger of being excluded from Scouts because his behaviour could not be efficiently managed while he was there. We were recently told by his Scout leader that for the last 6 weeks, George's behaviour has been exemplary.
Woo Hoo!!!!
He's off to Scout camp this weekend, and for the first time ever, I'm not worried that he'll be disruptive.
I really like this feeling. :o)
Friday, May 2, 2008
Three months in....
Our house is generally a calmer place and I've stopped grinding my teeth in my sleep.....
When we first started "doing Dore" I must be honest and say that I could not see how these silly little exercises would help. We have religiously kept to the routine, so I think this helps.
What changes have we seen? Well, they're very subtle ones, but already the improvement in our child has made the cost worthwhile.
He's quieter, generally, and those awful non-stop noises have all but gone. I can't remember the last time he made the popping noise (that was the one that drove me almost insane).
He still argues but before Dore he did not know when to stop and it caused so much tension in the house. The arguments now only last less than a minute (as opposed to up to an hour on bad days).
He's started to remember to do things! Oh my goodness, what a shock it was when he thought for himself and remembered to pack his PE kit, the night before! I nearly fell over....
I ask him to get the bins from the top of the drive and bring them down behind the house... he doesn't complain, he just does it... and the next shock..... he actually does it without messing about!
He still has lots of issues that need to be addressed, but to see these changes in these last couple of months gives me hope for his future.
I have a friend who is a Doctor and he was absolutely insistent that there is nothing that will "cure" ADHD. He sees it as a hormone imbalance in the brain, rather than a developmental problem which can be overcome. Interestingly, when he and I were having this debate, I received a message from a Mum who uses the Dore Talk Forum and she suggested that George may have Sensory Processing Disorder. As I understand it, this is another relatively new diagnosis to behavioural difficulties experienced by some children, and can be attributed to early years hearing loss. There's a reasonable amount of information out there regarding this, but the scary thing is that the main symptoms are more or less the same as ADHD. I started to wonder if George doesn't actually have ADHD, that perhaps he suffers from SPD because he has had hearing problems since he was 2 or 3 years old (and still does). I started to try and find out more information, but with a shortage of time, it got put on my "list of things to do".
I doubt that I will spend much time looking for more information, because I don't care. I really don't care what label people want to attach to my child. It doesn't matter. What matters, right now, is that The Dore Programme is helping where all manner of drugs and behaviour strategies failed.
How does George feel about the programme? Well, there have been a few times when he's moaned a bit about doing the exercises. I have a simple sentence which stops him in his tracks.
"That's OK George. You don't have to do them if you don't want to. As long as you know that you won't get better if you don't do them"
The look on his face.... it's like "Oh God, I don't want to be like this for the rest of my life" followed by "No Mum! I have to do them!"
Our next assessment is 6th May. I'm looking forward to it.
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
Where's my padded cell?
"Further to our telephone conversation this morning, I am pleased to tell you that I have now spoken to the English department, and have been advised that it would not be appropriate for George to move sets in this subject. However, I still have very grave concerns regarding this situation. Having spoken to Ms xxx, it seems that George finds it very difficult to settle in this class. The mix of pupils, I believe, is quite a problem. It would seem that there are a few pupils in the class who actively seek to antagonise George which results in his loss of self-control. We have tried to encourage George to ignore their taunts, but he finds it very difficult.
It would seem that the best way to help George (in this lesson) is to provide him with a 1-1 teaching assistant. However, I appreciate that resources are tight and this may not be possible. If George is not able to have a teaching assistant in English, I think it would be appropriate for him to have access to the special needs department on the occasions when he is not able to control his behaviour. This would enable George to work effectively and would also mean that the English teacher can teach the rest of the class. I would expect this to be at the Teachers discretion. Whilst we are not happy at the thought of George being excluded from the lesson, I cannot think of any other way, at the moment, to solve the problem.
You mentioned that it may be appropriate to put George on report, and get him to report to Mr xxxx. I am certainly willing to try this but our previous attempts to help George improve, using a report card, failed. My main concern, if a second attempt is made which doesn’t work, is that George will see this as yet another of his own failings. I will leave this decision up to you. If you think it will be beneficial to George, I will give my full support.
Finally, I would like to express my concern that George has to attend a detention, after school, on Monday 3rd March. I find it very difficult to understand why George is being punished for something he cannot help. George has a known and diagnosed disorder which includes impulsivity - lack of self control and lack of foresight. He is often deliberately antagonised by other pupils in his English class, which would certainly add fuel to the fire. His English teacher has confirmed this to me today. I realise that ADHD children can be extremely difficult to deal with but, if George were deaf, would he be punished for not listening properly?
He will be attending the detention, against my wishes, because it is important that he adhere to the school policy. However, I would like a full explanation as to why this punishment was deemed necessary."
Sadly, there was no intervention and George attended for detention. I hate this situation, with a passion. I even considered giving him the meds again, until we see an improvement through the Dore Programme. However, once I had calmed down (had a bit of a temper tantrum, stamped my feet and cried) I decided that my original resolution would have to be followed. At the moment, if we return to the meds, George may see this as another failure and he really needs to succeed in something right now....In the meantime, George has added to his list of people who hate him. He came home from school on Monday (after detention) with mud all over the front and back of his trousers, all over his school coat and also his school bag. Evidently two of the main antagonists pushed him over... (once each). He's angry and I don't blame him.
We haven't had a response yet, to the letter we sent. Himself has returned home and he isn't as patient as me. I think the school will be hearing from him.
How's the Dore going? He's still right there, 100%. He really wants it to work. We haven't noticed any improvement as yet, but it's only been three weeks.... not that I'm impatient or anything......
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
Taking the plunge...
Following an assessment at the Dore clinic last week, it was recommended that George start the programme. I have been following a number of on-line forums which discuss the success (or failure) of children on this programme. It would seem that a number of ADHD children have benefited substantially. There are, of course, those that have completed the course and have not benefited in any way. It doesn’t work for everybody.
George has an exercise regime specifically targeted to help him develop skills in areas where he has demonstrated a weakness. He has a set of three exercises, of which he must carry out two, twice a day. Each exercise must be done for a total of 5 days and then he moves on to a different exercise. At the moment they are quite easy for him, but we are focusing on the importance of control. Because they are quite quickly rotated I am hopeful that they will hold his interest and won’t become a chore for him. Also, when he has completed each exercise, I am hopeful that this will help to boost his confidence and he will start to believe that he can learn to control his actions.
It was explained to me that most children get worse before they get better, and I have read anecdotal evidence that backs this up. It generally seems to occur at about the 8-10 week stage. This is seen as a positive thing, because it would appear that for those children who initially regress, the long term outcome is generally very good.
Once he has mastered the physical exercises, he will be presented with some mental exercises which he must do at the same time as the physical ones. This normally happens at around the six month stage. My understanding of this process is that this will teach his brain to multi-task – this is something that he does not seem to be able to do currently and I believe that this may be the key to unlock his ability to control himself.
Currently, George has a very positive attitude regarding this. He really wants to try to help himself. We have a follow up appointment in six weeks time (and every six weeks thereafter) for further assessment, at which time his programme can be adjusted to suit his progress.
The Dore Programme is really still in its infancy, despite being around for a number of years. I watched a short interview today, featuring Kenny Logan, who has completed the Dore Programme to help with Dyslexia. He maintains that he couldn't read a word before he was 30. He said, with the help of the Dore programme, that he is now learning more every day. He learnt his vowels at 30 years old, has now learnt how to break down words (much like a child does, when they first learn to read) and feels that he is going from strength to strength. He explained how his Mother arranged for extra tutoring but even though he tried hard, he couldn't get the information to stay in his brain - he said he couldn't process it adequately to be able to retain it. George is not dyslexic, but I feel that there is some mileage to be gained by giving it a good try. Parents of ADHD children realise, quite quickly, that you can explain to your child how damaging their inappropriate behaviour is, but they cannot retain or process the information. We are often seen as poor parents because we know there is no point going on, and on, and on at the child. It won't make any difference because after 5 minutes they will have forgotten...... We can't spend our lives banging our heads against a brick wall, upsetting the whole family and gaining.... precisely nothing.
I am relieved that George has been accepted on the programme. At least I know that we are doing everything we can to help him. I have to be positive and believe that this will work. I hope that this positive attitude will help and encourage George to see it through to the end.
Monday, February 4, 2008
Pass the steak....
Both are sleeping peacefully now which gives me time to beat myself up. I ask myself if there was any way I could have prevented this happening and the only answer I come up with is to supervise him constantly. He's 11 years old and doesn't want his Mother following him around the house "just in case" he does something he shouldn't. I know he would hate it, and his logic would tell him that he can't be trusted and that would push his self esteem even lower. I know he will suffer, inside, because of this incident. As parents, we have to explain that his actions where inappropriate. This is what parents must do. I also know that by explaining how wrong he was, it will push him one step further down the ladder. At the moment, for every one step up he takes, his lack of control makes him move down two steps. He is, without doubt, a very caring and loving child. He was distraught when he realised what he had done and would have done anything to be able to undo it. I want to be able to save him from himself, but I cannot be there, every second of every day to second guess what he may do next.
10 days until we go to the Dore centre for his assessment. I'm praying they can help him.
Thursday, January 31, 2008
For my next trick.....
George is in the garage with his Dad, right now. They're welding. George is very good at it. He needs to end the day on a positive note.
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Monopoly isn't supposed to be so hard!
Trying to think of something positive about today, I came up with this:
Today, he cleaned his school shoes without arguing about it first. :o)
Friday, January 18, 2008
Not two hours later, we received a call from his Scout leader requesting that George was collected from Scouts because his behaviour was just too bad. We had explained to him (again!), before he went to scouts, the importance of behaving in an acceptable way. It doesn't make any difference how much we try, he just cannot seem to get it to sink in.
He came home, very unhappy because he had been excluded (understandable!) and was sent to bed. As he rushed past me, the distraught look on his face reduced me to tears. He sobbed for a while and eventually calmed down. He explained to me that he knows that he needs to try and stop doing the things that annoy and irritate others..... he has always known this but by the time he realises that his behaviour is not acceptable, it's too late. Any mother struggles to deal with their emotions when a child of theirs is so unhappy. Frustrations abound on all sides - our child is frustrated with himself because of his inability to control himself and we are frustrated with ourselves because of our inability to help him.
There is no support from the professionals because a) the lack of resources and personnel mean that too few people are trying to manage too many cases and b) we have withdrawn the Ritalin which is going directly against the doctors' recommendation.
It brings to mind the old cliché:
"We're damned if we do, and we're damned if we don't"
Sunday, January 13, 2008
In the beginning.....
George started 'play school' when he was two and a half. Within a few weeks, there were queries regarding his inability to sit still. I put it down to a very active imagination, along with a tendency towards hyperactivity. My understanding though, of hyperactive children, was that they rarely slept and because George had outgrown his sleeplessness, he couldn't be clinically hyperactive (in my opinion). We muddled through the following two and a half years until he started Primary school at age four and a half. By this time, we had a fourth child - a daughter - who was, and still is, an angel. George had also developed Asthma and was taking a steroid inhaler to treat this. We discovered that, within 3 days of using the inhaler, he would become overly aggressive and we found out that this is a side effect of steroid inhalers (why do doctors never tell you this?). We used to send a note into school:
"George had an asthma attack at the weekend and used his inhaler. This is your three day warning!"
His first year teacher queried ADHD. I didn't know too much about it, but at the time I was going through my "I'm a bad mother - it's my fault" phase and generally beating myself up about his bad behaviour. I told her that he couldn't possibly have it because he is able to concentrate for long(ish) periods of time when he's involved in something he really loves.
Around this time, we looked at the possibility of food intolerances being the main cause of his hyperactivity and impulsive behavour. The following two years saw George eating only natural food - no additives, preservatives, sugar or colourings. We also started giving him omega 3 fish oils.
It took two years to get an appointment with the allergy specialist at our local hospital. I was convinced that once we got the diagnosis, we could then start to include other foods in his diet. George had a pin-prick test, using the most common triggers of food allergies (eggs, wheat, milk, peanuts) and he was also tested for airborn allergens (house dust mites, dogs, cats and horses etc). The result was that he showed one reaction - to house dust mites - and this was the cause of his asthma. A further two years and I managed to control the asthma without using steroid inhalers. We steam clean the house once a month to keep the house dust mite allergens down to a minimum and, at the time of writing, George has been asthma free for nearly four years. :o)
As a result of his allergy testing, we abandoned the "totally natural" diet, although have always tried to keep his sugar intake to a minimum. We noticed no difference. Therefore, I had proved to myself that his behaviour was not due to eating modern food.
Back to the plot.....
His year two teacher found a strategy that worked for George and thoughts of ADHD disappeared because he now seemed to be behaving like any other normal, although very active, 6 year old.
His year three teacher couldn't cope AT ALL. I remember the day when she stormed across the playground at the end of the day, with George in tow, and told me "I don't think there's anything wrong with him - I just think he's a very naughty boy!" I cried all the way home..... That evening, George informed me that he thought I should leave home. When I asked him why, he said "because I can't be good". :o(
Around this time, George developed suicidal tendencies and his self esteem was in minus figures. We had tried many different strategies to help him, all of which failed, so we decided that George should be assessed for ADHD. We got a referral through our GP, completed the Connors assessment and waited for an appointment.
And waited....
And waited....
After 12 months of waiting I telephoned our local ADHD clinic and had a bit of a temper tantrum about the waiting time. George was getting worse.... his little sister was, by now, copying all his bad behaviour and I had visions of having two children attend this clinic for some considerable part of their lives. The thought of having another child on the waiting list seemed to spur them into action and we received our appointment within four weeks. Finally, I felt as though we were making some progress.
On the day of our appointment, the psychologist confirmed that George was indeed afflicted with ADHD (he had a connors rating of 27/30) and he was prescribed Ritalin. (I am aware that the process for dealing with ADHD in children has changed slightly since George was diagnosed and other options are available these days).
It was like a miracle cure for us. His behaviour at school improved drastically and his schoolwork improved almost overnight. We felt that he now had good prospects for the future (and I'm not talking academically).
This is the background, very much condensed.
Lets skip four years...... and come (almost) to present day......
At age 11, we were finding it increasingly difficult to reconcile with the fact that George was taking 40 - 50mg of Ritalin a day. I was also increasingly concerned about the long term effects of taking a stimulant drug. I wanted to get him off the Ritalin, but had a lot of concerns. These were my thoughts, fears and hopes:
A reduced dose will not really work. Too little and you might as well not bother with it. We have discussed this in depth quite recently, himself and I. I want to try and get him off the stuff, and himself suggested a half dose. His dosage has recently been increased because 15mg just wasn't doing the business any more. Children grow and Georges' normal (previous) dose was based on his weight. He was becoming less focussed at school and his teachers were struggling. Without the Ritalin, it's real struggle, more than you can know, unless you live with a child who has ADHD.
They say that knowledge is power. To try and increase my knowledge I have recently read a book called "the Edison gene".
As a result of this, and other research I have carried out over the past few years, I am trying to look at my child through more positive eyes. Let us imagine for a moment, if 90% of our children were like George. The educational system would be set up to teach these children according to their attitude to learning. ADHD children are the most enquiring and alert. They do not respond well to our current teaching methods because they are constantly scanning. They do not see the benefit in being taught the 7 times table. They do see the benefit in experimenting, exploring and inventing because these are activities that stretch the imagination and keep them focussed on "what could be possible". To teach these children effectively, they need to be able to work at their own pace and bypass what is irrelevant to them. Our education system will always be tailored to meet the needs of the majority. The minority will be pushed to one side because
"I have 27 other children in the class - I cannot possibly give this child special attention"
"I cannot cope with him first thing - he's too lively"
"He gets easily bored - I don't know what to do to keep him interested in the subject matter"
If the majority of children were like George, teaching would take a more "hands on" approach. It would be more structured towards physically doing, rather than just being talked to. As an example:
Thomas Edison was a prolific inventor. At age 16 he devised a railway signalling system that was used for nearly 100 years. Thomas Edison had ADHD. His mother removed him from the education system because she could see the harm that was caused by un-informed teachers and their inability to deal with children who did not conform to what was accepted as normal. As a result he was allowed to develop into the person he was capable of being. At the end of this I will tell you more about him and how he would fit into todays society.
I want my child to develop into the man he needs to be to get the most from his life. I am frustrated by the lack of understanding. I have read many articles by nutritionists who have poo-poo'd ADHD, saying that it is completely down to todays diet of junk food, additives and preservatives. They say that if we fed our children natural food - fresh meat, vegetables and fruit etc., all these symptons would miraculously disappear. In my experience this is not true. It is true that if you have a hyperactive child that you should avoid too much sugar. Sugar is an "instant" energy food, and will give the recipient a sudden abundance of energy. Sugar free drinks are just as bad for a child with ADHD because they react to the artificial sweetener. We tried for 2 years to control this disorder through diet - it had no effect at all, except to give me a good knowledge of E numbers!
So, the diet has no effect, and he cannot conform in the way that our society deems acceptable. 20,000 years ago he would have been the leader of a group of hunters, due to his amazing ability to constantly scan, to be able to jump instantly from one activity to another.
Today, we give our children a mind altering drug to force them to conform. In one way, this is a positive thing because it enables them to integrate with our "normal" society. The other side of the coin shows that we are inhibiting the amazing gift these children have been born with, which will leave them............. where...?
I have seen what my child is capable of. He is 11 years old and has recently built and programmed a robot (with the aid of written instructions). I want to enable him to grow his capabilities in the way that suits him. He is not like other children and I don't want to give him drugs to make him like other children.
There is a theory that children who take ritalin are inhibited from learning how to be "socially acceptable". They cannot learn that skill because the drugs automatically stunt their ability to learn through doing. In other words, they understand the theory but do not have the practical ability. Added to that is the unknown effect of long term ritalin usage. There are some adults, having taken ritalin to control ADHD in childhood, who are reporting short term memory problems. It's not known if the short term memory problems are due to taking ritalin, or if it is a long term symptom of ADHD.
This unknown element scares me and that's another reason to try to get him off the drugs. I want him to be able to learn how to control his impulses. He cannot do this while he is taking ritalin.
The following passage had a profound effect on me, and has made me think about what is best for my boy in the long term
Yesterday's child was born in the 1800's. As a young boy, he was considered medically fragile. Every respiratory illness known to mankind in that age seemed to seize him. Even though Yesterday's child spent many of his early years ill, this did not stop his insatiable curiosity and boyish escapades. Today's child would be described as "just being a boy."
Yesterday's child often found himself in risky life-and-death situations. One time, around the age of five, this boy nearly drowned in a canal; and later he almost smothered as he sank into the depths of a grain elevator. Today's child would be described as "having no common sense."
Yesterday's child was found asleep in the barn in a nest he had constructed, lying on top of the chicken and goose eggs he was trying to hatch. Today's child would be called "weird, eccentric." "Get off those eggs, you'll crack them!"
Yesterday's child drove his parents to exhaustion by his persistent questioning of the world around him, determined to know the "whys," "what fors," and "what abouts" of his world. Todays child is searching for someone to ask the questions to
Yesterdays child, with no malice aforethought but only out of the intense curiosity of an inquisitive mind, set his father's barn on fire. For this he was publicly thrashed by his father, who tried to instill in him the serious consequences of his actions. Todays child would be called a "juvenile delinquent".
After only three months of formal education, Yesterdays child walked out of his school in a fit of rage. Running home, he could hear the thoughts of the schoolmaster echoing in his head: "stupid... stubborn... difficult." Thus, at the tender age of eight, Yesterdays mother gave the schoolmaster a piece of her mind and withdrew the boy from school. From that day onward, she became Yesterday's teacher. Todays child would be called "a problem child, a bad boy, oppositional." And Today's mother would be told she was "highly excitable, and coddling her child." She would be encouraged by all the experts to force her child to return to school because "He'll outgrow it. He's got to learn to adjust."
Yesterdays child went swimming with a friend in a nearby creek. When the friend didn't surface for air, Yesterday's child waited for what seemed like forever. As darkness fell, he - in his own unique five-year-old logic - concluded that it was time to go home. As the town was trying to piece together the disappearance and drowning of his friend, Yesterdays child tried to explain how he waited for what seemed like forever... Todays child would be treated for "conduct disorder" and undoubtedly find himself one step away from the juvenile justice system.
Yesterdays child just couldn't comprehend consequences; that much seems true. One day he attached wires to the tails of two cats and energetically rubbed their fur. This experiment in static electricity went astray when he was brutally clawed. Todays child would be in long term therapy for ADHD, Pervasive Development Disorder, or some other behavioural disorder.
Yesterdays mother complained constantly about the life-threatening condition of his bedroom. Fearing for the safety of her family and any other who ventured into the family home, Yesterdays mother moved his experiments into the cellar. Yesterdays child called it his laboratory and immersed himself in science, to the exclusion of what other "normal" kids were doing at his age. Todays child would be labelled "dysfunctional." Todays child would be spending time in a court order alternative school programme, meeting with a psychiatrist twice a week for therapy, and be attending a class to learn social skills.
At age twelve Yesterdays child insisted on going to work and began successfully earning his own wage. Todays child, at that age, would face a closed door to the world of mentorship in the workplace. Todays child would have to search beyond home and work for other avenues to have his abilities accepted and appreciated.
As you read about yesterdays child, you are probably wondering how he could have survived and how he could have contributed to society in a positive way. Clearly, yesterdays child had somebody who accepted his uniqueness, changed his environment to meet his needs, was not intimidated by his gifts, and tried sincerely to see the world through his eyes.
Yesterdays child's name is Thomas Alva Edison.
I am not saying that my child will be this clever, but I want to give him the opportunity to be all that he can be.
Our biggest problem currently is with the school. I can just about deal with him, un-medicated, at home. We have agreed that the school will not be able to cope. This is because they don't seem to want to understand where he's coming from. The SeNco is a waste of space, in my opinion. She was his year 5 teacher and his general attitude to learning, whilst in her class, deteriorated. In year 6, she still takes him for a few lessons a week. She complained that he doesn't concentrate well in her class and gets easily bored. A basic understanding of kids with ADHD would give her the answer to this problem. Kids like this need to succeed and be recognised for their little successes - there has to be something positive in their lives. As an example: he has an amazing ability to design and construct. Both his Y5 and Y6 teachers have specifically requested that he does NOT take any of his completed projects into school because they are made from lego and toys are not allowed. They have not seen his robot.
The other ongoing problem is how he stands out by being different. We all know that children can be unkind and very often will target kids who are different. George has been targeted and often comes out of school at the end of the day, unhappy and frustrated, because some of the other children deliberately wind him up and then mock him when he over-reacts.
It bothers me that his teachers are only happy when George has made himself invisible. Comments like: "He was very good in art, today. In fact, I didn't even realise he was there" make me want to bang my head against a brick wall. This child has such a rich personality but nobody at school is interested. Two months ago his Y6 teacher asked me if there was any way I could give him his meds earlier, because he's very lively first thing, but by 9.15 he has settled down a bit. After I explained the consequences of this - his second dose would have worn off by 2.30 and she would have a hour "full on" at the end of the day, she decided to keep it as it is.
She told me that he will not go up to the playground, first thing, to play and instead comes running into the classroom 10 minutes early, wanting to help her. The example she gave me was that he wanted to fill the glue pots. In my opinion, this is a good thing and would be beneficial to all - he doesn't like playing in the playground - there's no structure to it and there is too much stimulus - he cannot cope with it. The task he suggested for himself would be quite therapeutic and something he could concentrate on (clever boy!) She refused to allow him to help. Instead she sent him back outside, and then complained that he spent 10 minutes messing about, before coming back in with the rest of the children. By this time he was completely off his head with boredom and took another half an hour to calm down. It's interesting that she seems so desperate to control him through his medication but when I've suggested possible alternatives, she looks down her nose at me. I don't really blame her for that - after all, she's a trained professional, but I know my child better than her and my suggestions (and his) should be given some merit. These two teachers consistently demonstrate a total lack of understanding with regard to him. My ADHD nurse rang the school to offer support and to my knowledge this has been turned down on the basis that they are managing perfectly well, thank you. Because of this we have decided that it would be best for George to have a full dose of Ritalin on school days, with complete breaks on non school days (on the non-ritalin days we are giving him Omega-3 oils to blunt his pointy edges
He only has 6 weeks left at his current school and to be honest I don't think there's much more that we can achieve, given the short space of time. We plan to give him a summer that is medication free, in an effort to help him learn some self control. He responds well to people who believe in him. He has attended two camping weekends with his scout troop and they have experienced very few problems. Part of this is down to the activities, and part of it is due to his respect for his scout leader who believes that George can do well (and George can sense this).
I have also started to employ two very useful phrases:
"Just try it one more time. I know you can do it."
"It's not about how fast you can do it, it's about how well you can do it"
Both of these simple phrases are starting to work (albeit v e r y s l o w l y). If I can show him that I believe in him, I hope that he will start to believe in himself.
The senior school that he will be attending in September seems to be more pro-active and I have more confidence regarding support. I have an appointment with the SeNco next week, and once I know more about their strategies I can make an informed decision regarding his medication.
He doesn't seem to be at all worried about going to the "big" school. He's almost like a little warrior and I think he sees it as an exciting new adventure. If he started to show any signs of stress, I know that by reinforcing the "exciting adventure" aspect he would happily accept the situation. I have to be positive about his new school because he's very aware of undercurrents of tension and if he thinks I have any negative feelings about it, he will automatically assume that it's because I don't think he can do it. My main concern is that his new teachers will need to have an open mind regarding George. I know that he can achieve much, given the right motivation and respect.
For him, personally, he will struggle to be accepted for the person he is. He comes out with such funny things and he won't stop to think about how it will be perceived by others.
One of our friends often comments on how George made him laugh when he asked:
"What have you been up to then, George?"
George was watching a natural history programme, so his reply was short and to the point:
"I went to Nethercott Farm last week and I've just done a pooh."
He never once took his eyes off the TV.
He often reminds me of Jerry Lewis in the Nutty Professor!
The above is an extract of my thoughts, which were written some six months ago. We are on the verge of some huge changes and this blog is my way of keeping track of where we've been, and where we're going.
George moved up to the senior school in September 2007. For the first 6 weeks he attended, he had his normal Ritalin dose every day, and our daily hell began at 4pm when the drugs had worn off. The arguments, mood swings, noises (which I describe as similar to Tourettes) and general inappropriate behaviour had become a very unhappy way of life. The school, however, had been very supportive and I decided that now was a good time to dispense with the meds. During the Autumn half term, we discarded the Ritalin. This was done with the full knowledge of his specialist who recommended that we continued to give him the drugs. I told him I needed to find a better way. I begged him to help me. He told me that he couldn't recommend any other way because Ritalin was the only thing that has been clinically tested. And of course.... it works. I am not denying that, for George, the Ritalin was a quick fix. But, I keep coming back to the worry of the long term side effects.........
We have identified a possible alternative which may help our child. It's a 12 month long training programme that is supposed to help to develop the "broken" neural pathways which prevent George from being able to learn the consequences of his actions. It is supposed to teach him how to manage his daily life and to find ways to keep his over-active mind focussed on the task at hand. His initial assessment is on 13th February 2008. Between now and the end of the course, I aim to update this blog as often as I can. If you accidentally stumble across this, and find it of interest, please leave your comments.
Today, George wrapped an elastic band around one of the cats' paws. I don't know how long it had been there when I found it, but the poor creatures' paw had started to swell. George forgot that he had done it and looked distraught when I showed him. The cat, and George, have both recovered well.